Discussion: Can Overrated Also Be Good?

I often find myself reading or watching something that has a lot of hype. Sometimes they meet my expectations, other times, they don’t. But I usually find reviews giving them a low rating because they’re “overrated”. 

My question is: should the hype surrounding something affect the overall subject matter? Should the fuss ruin the experience for people? Let’s look: 

Book: The Mortal Instruments

I had seen this series around FOR YEARS. I swore never to read it due to the hype; I was worried I’d be disappointed. But then I read The Infernal Devices….and fell head over heels. I read TMI as fast as I could. And as much as I enjoyed certain books, some parts of the series were lacking for me. I wasn’t as invested in the majority of the characters as TID, or the main couple. I felt like, in the second part especially, arcs could’ve been shortened or condensed without the series suffering. So did I find this series overrated? Yes. But I can understand the hype; the world building is unique, the characters are interesting and realistic, and the diversity is introduced so naturally, that even if the character’s diversity was their story, I didn’t mind. Because they felt less like a symbol of some minority group, and felt like a real person, likely because the Shadowhunter culture is reminiscent of the early 20th century at best. And City of Glass and City of Heavenly Fire were amazing too. Did I enjoy this as much as TID, or even what I’ve read of Lady Midnight so far? No. But I did enjoy this, and I do think this deserves such a dedicated fan base. 

TV: Supernatural:

Everyone has heard of this by now. Started in 2005, and the fandom is as strong as ever. I started watching this because everyone at school loved it…and after episode three,  I promptly called a friend and begged her if season 1 was skippable. It  was dull to me, the stories cliché. She did say I could skip season 1, told me about what happened, and I moved into season 2. Season 2 was definitely better. And yet, this show is clustered in with Doctor Who and Sherlock all the time, which I disagree with. I like the other two shows much more. Supernatural is a fun series, but I found the same problems as I did with TMI; I wasn’t as invested as I had expected to be. I felt as though it was too cliché, but I still enjoyed it. I still enjoy it now. The acting is really, really good, it can be funny and moving, the effects are cool, and I like that they use underrated monsters. I just feel as if there’s too much filler for me to be engrossed in this. However, I still watch this and like it. Just not as much as everyone else. It’s a good show, but it simply isn’t my exact cup of tea.

Anime: Attack on Titan:

I wasn’t interested in this until I saw some animation and art. Immediately, I knew I had to watch this, it looked that stunning. I   seriously enjoyed this my first time watching; the characters were intriguing, the animation gorgeous, the soundtrack awesome, and the story unique. However, there are problems: there’s melodrama, the pacing is slow, characters with potential were killed off before I could become really attached to them, and I found characters like Levi and Mikasa to be really overrated. The melodrama made me feel apathetic to scenes that were supposed to be “sad” or “tragic”. The slowness of the Trost arc irritated me, especially as it introduced incredibly important details but just dragged on. While I did find Levi to be interesting, he just wasn’t shown enough for me to love the character as much as everyone else.  I also found Mikasa to be a good character deep down, but she just has poor writing that makes her seem shallow, creepily obsessive, and a bit of a Mary Sue with how naturally good she is at everything. My biggest pet peeve was the character deaths: each character I started to like, or started to find interesting, died before I could have a proper emotional connection with them. This made me less worried that characters I actually liked would die. However, this anime is still amazing, and I really did love it. I find the good points outweigh the bad points, at least with me. So yes, I do think this is worthy of praise…but it is overrated. 

Movie: La La Land:

La La Land was one of the movies at the Oscars I had actually heard of, and boy, I’d heard a lot about how amazing it was. So I went to see it and loved it, even if I found it a little overly hyped; it was a bit too slow for me, and while the songs were good, only a few were truly memorable to me. I don’t have as much to say about this as with others, but I can say that this isn’t for everyone. I don’t know how to describe it, it just isn’t. It’s more artsy and a character study than a story, and it is definitely a deconstruction of the classic Hollywood romance. I think that not hearing as much about this as everyone else did me good in my enjoying it. 

Webtoon: Tower of God:

This is a strange choice for me to put in here, as this is the only DNF (besides Supernatural, which I’m still watching) on the article. Anyway, TOG is one of the most popular Webtoons, along with Noblesse and Girls of the Wild‘s. So I tried reading it. At first I thought it was fine: the story was interesting, the Tower was unique, there were plenty of characters, and I’d heard that the art improved drastically. Yet I never got into it for some reason. I dunno about whether it was because the world was so complicated, or because there were only three characters I really cared about or not, but this wasn’t for me. But from what I had read,I  understand why everyone loves it so much. The characters were all unique, the Tower was so intriguing, and the world felt incredibly realistic. So while I just couldn’t get into it, I really wish I could; this looked amazing. It just isn’t my thing.

After writing about these hyped pieces of fiction, I’m thinking that there may be stories that fell flat for me, but it’s ultimately me: I heard the hype, elevated my expectations high, and was disappointed. But do I think that some fandoms shouldn’t hype  some things up too much? Yeah. They sometimes treat fiction like it’s flawless, and can’t understand how someone wouldn’t like something. This is a very subjective, emotional area. Overall, this is an area that simply depends on an individual’s tastes, and I say: Don’t always bash on overrated things because they’re overrated. If you didn’t like something, give more substantial reasons than that. And acknowledge whether something is good, even if you didn’t like it. And fandoms: don’t treat something like it’s perfect. Nothing is, and your love of it may decrease other’s enjoyment of it. 

22 thoughts on “Discussion: Can Overrated Also Be Good?

  1. The first couple seasons of supernatural in my opinion are the best. The show is still great after that but I love the first more. I’m sorry that you hated it the season so much.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. It simply isn’t my cup of tea. I could see the potential, but I also found it rather slow and boring, but I just couldn’t get into it. I want to, but it’s not my thing. Glad to see someone else didn’t care for it either! I’m not insane!


  2. I can relate so much to this. I tend to stay away from some overly hyped things.
    I’ve never read ToG, but I always remember seeing nothing but good comments about it; I never read it because it didn’t really seem like my thing. Also I’ve never seen AOT either. I remember, before I started liking anime, watching people react to seeing AOT for the first time, and I got scared of it because I saw all the Titans. (I’m so easily scared. 😅) Now that I’m more into anime, AOT is always mentioned whenever I look at any anime related posts or fanart. (But I’m still unsure about watching it.)
    However, when I was new to the book world, I’ve never heard of Cassie Clare before, so I gave her books a try and was hooked; it was later when I realized the hype surrounding all of them. (Same goes for Sherlock, I’ve never heard of a TV series being made, but I watched it because I didn’t know their was a fandom behind it. Not that I don’t love the fandom. 😉)
    So I found out that if I don’t the hype around something, I’ll probably end up watching/reading it, but the hype tends to make me shy away.
    On rare occasions, I’d like to be in on the fandom, so I’ll watch the anime or read the books to know a little more background.
    This was such a wordy comment, but hey, wordy comments are fun to read. 😀

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Same, but sometimes I try to read and watch them anyway.
      I also heard nothing but good things about TOG too, which is why I tried to read it. It just didn’t click with me.
      AOT is actually really good for such a hyped up anime. The Titans never really scared me, to be honest. Even though it isn’t a perfect show, I still really enjoyed it and I recommend you watch it, at least for the animation and soundtrack (even though I liked the storyline and most of the characters!).
      Huh! That’s interesting. I’d heard of Clare for a while, but it took TID to get me into her books.
      And with Sherlock, my parents actually got me into it. A friend recommended it, and we all got hooked.
      I don’t blame you with the hype thing; I typically try to stay away from those, but my curiosity gets the better of me. And wordy comments are awesome, I love them!

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I can understand that for ToG. I bet it’s good in the eyes of a lot of people, just not all.
        And maybe I’ll consider watching AOT sometime! It wasn’t just the Titans, but some gore (however I’m over with the gore thing so it’ll be easier to watch). And if the soundtrack is that good, consider me sold.
        I think I heard of Cassie in fleeting moments, but I didn’t really know what her books were about. I just saw them one day, and decided to read it. 🙂
        A friend got me into Sherlock too, and in turn I introduced it to some other friends and got them hooked. 😄
        I’m glad you understand the hype thing, but sometimes I get curious too and decide to watch/read whatever peeks my interest. 😊

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Ah. I understand about gore (that’s why I stayed away for a while too) but I’m also pretty much over it. And yeah, the soundtrack is awesome! I even bought it on iTunes.
        Huh, that’s interesting. I’d just been hearing about her for a while, and randomly checked out Clockwork Angel.
        Haha, and it’s so much fun to get other people hooked o your stuff!

        Liked by 1 person

  3. Yeah, it looked like the term “overrated” and the hype behind it personally affects you. But that’s part of it, really. Some things are often blown out of proportions, and you come into it hoping for something that clearly wasn’t as good as advertised.
    I respect some things being “overrated” though, because it just means a lot of people like it. For me, it doesn’t personally bother me if people worship something. I remember Logan being preached to death, and the movie wasn’t really as good as it could be. I think the challenging part of a great piece is if its able to not get dragged down by its overhype. If its truly good, then that’ll persist above all else. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    1. That’s what I wanted to communicate; that something is often fussed over too much, causing someone to raise their expectations ridiculously high. And ‘overrated’ things should often be respected, even if it isn’t your thing (that’s how I feel with Tower of God; I couldn’t get into it, but I respect it for the following its generated). I haven’t seen Logan, so that’s an interesting perspective of it. And there have been pieces of fiction that for me at least, did manage to not be taken down by the hype. That’s always impressive.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Totally agree. I tend to avoid overhyped things… At first. But I don’t think my enjoyment once I do try them is any less or any more because of my preconceived ideas. Of course, our subconscious is a tricky thing so I’m not sure.
    As a general rule, I’ll try not to judge something too much until I’ve tried. Unless it’s something I really had no interest in to begin with.
    Another amazing post! 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  5. The little I have seen of Supernatural I enjoyed. Reminds me a bit of X-Files. Attack on Titan is a great show, but a tad overrated. I never understood why it became so popular, even with non-anime fans, because there are other shows out there that are just as good.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I like Supernatural, but I think it was the fact that it was constantly being compared to Sherlock and Doctor Who (two of my favorite shows) that made my expectations too high. I never got as emotionally invested in it as I wanted to. And I have to admit I preferred the X-Files a bit more. Attack on Titan is good, but yeah, overrated. I also think there are other shows that are better, but I still enjoyed it quite a bit (and since I’m trying out the free 30 days things on Hulu, I can watch some of Season 2!)

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s